Monthly Archives: December 2014

Is “Fara’id al-Samtayn” a Sunni book?

اسلام علیکم

Is “Fara’id al-Samtayn” or “Fara’id al-Samtain” or “Faraid al-Simtayn” a Sunni book?

I will just post the cover of the book on this thread but you can read this article and this one that proves in detail that this book and the author belong to the Shia not Sunnis.



This cover even has the name of the Muhaqiq (researcher) of the book:



As you can see it is written on the covers:

مؤسّسة المحمودي للطباعة والنشر بيروت ـ لبنان

حقّقه وعلّق عليه وتصدّى لنشره الشيخ محمّد باقر المحمودي

al-Mahmoudi printing and publishing house/institute – this is a Shia publishing house

Muhaqiq (researcher) of the book is Shia scholar Shaykh Muhammad Baqir Mahmoudi (the publishing house is named after him)

And this is ‘Shaykh Muhammad Baqir Mahmoudi’ responsible for the publishing of the book.



Original article link

Posted by 13S2010


Leave a comment

Filed under Exposing, Revealing Shia sect

Shia Infallible Imam was not knowledgeable – as per Shia narrations.

Seventh divinely appointed infallible Imam of Twelver Shia, Musa ‘al-Kadhim’ was not knowledgeable – as per Shia narrations. 

By brother al-a3sha

The famous Shia narrator Abu Baseer attested to the fact that Al-Khadem was not very knowledgable. Al-Khoei said in Rijal Al-Hadith Vol 15 p. 154:

“Al-Shayk (i.e Al-Tusi) narrated this last narration through an isnad which could be considered, with a slight change in wording. He narrated through his isnad upto Ali Ibn Al-Hassan from Shuayb Al-Aqerkufi he said:” I asked Abu Al-Hassan (a.s)”… until he said: “and then I mentioned that to Abu Baseer (i.e the fatwa of Al-Khadem which is detailed in the next narration) so he said to me: by Allah Jafar (a.s) said: The woman is to be stoned and the man is to be flogged a hundred times as Hadd. And then he took his hands and placed them over his chest scratching it and saying: I do not think that the knowledge of one we are following has become complete yet (i.e referring to Al-Khazim).”

(Ref,: Al-Tahdeeb Vol 7. Chapter on additional (topics) with regards to Fiqdh of Marriage, Hadith # 1957, as well as Al-Istibsar Vol 3, Chapter on Man marrying a woman and then knowing after having relation with her that she has a husband. Hadith # 687)

He also narrated the content of this hadith through his chain upto Ahmad Ibn Muhammad from Ibn Abi Umair from Shuaib that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hassan (a.s) about a man marrying a married woman. He said: They have to be separated. I asked: Is he to be flogged? He said: No , he is not to be flogged. So I departed him, while Abu Baseer was next to the Meez-ab (i.e of the Kaaba) so I informed him about the question and answer. He said to me: Where am I? I said: you are next to the Meez-ab. He then lifted his hand and said: By the Lord of this House , or by the Lord of this Kaaba, I have heard Jafar say that Ali (a.s) gave a judgment about the man marrying a married woman that the woman be stoned and the man be flogged as Hadd. He then said: Had I known that you have known I would have bruised your head with stones. He then said: I am so scared that he (i.e Al-Khadem ) was not given his knowledge.

(Ref: Al-Tahdeeb Vol 10 Chapter on Hudud of adultery, hadith # 76)”


Filed under Infallibility issues with shia imams