Answering famous Shia scholar about Abubakr

read onFamous Shi’i scholar Ibn Mutahhar al-Hilli said while speaking about Abu Bakr:

“The Prophet (sallallahu ‘alaihi wa sallam) did not appoint him as a leader in any matter during his lifetime… And when he sent him with Bara’ah he took him back after three days. So how any sane person would accept the leadership (of whole Ummah) of someone who is not liked by the Prophet, through the revelation from Allah, for the conveying of even ten verses of Bara’ah.”


This is utter falsehood to claim that Abu Bakr As-Siddiq was not appointed as an Ameer in any matter. We are sure about the following cases:

1. Hajj during 9 AH

2. Imam of Prayer

3. Expedition towards Banu Fizarah during 7 AH

There is no dispute regarding his leadership during Hajj in 9 AH and even Al-Hilli accepted it but he claimed that he Abu Bakr (ra) was replaced by ‘Ali (ra) after three days. However there is no evidence to suggest it. Sunni sources almost unanimous that Ali (ra) was sent to announce the Bara’ah not as an Imam. In fact, Ibn Ishaq reports through Hakeem b. Hakeem b. ‘Abbad from Abu Ja’far al-Baqar that when ‘Ali (ra) reached, Abu Bakr asked him, “You have come to lead or to be leaded” [i.e. Ameer or Ma’moor]. He replied, “Rather to be leaded.” [Al-Bidayah, Seerah Ibn Hisham] This isnad is Hasan as Ibn Ishaq has mentioned his hearing from Hakeem.

Abu Hurairah (ra) was the one who used to announce Bara’ah alongside ‘Ali (ra) as it has been reported authentically from him in Sahih. Bukhari (1622, 4363,4655, 4657).

As for Imamah of Abu Bakr As-Siddiq in prayer then it is as much famous and mutawatir that no sane person would deny it.

Regarding his leadership in the expedition towards Banu Fizarah then it is mentioned by Ibn Katheer in al-Bidayah,Ibn Sa’d in Tabaqat etc and its hadith has been reported by Muslim, Ahmad etc.

Written by Muhammad Moin
Posted here by 13S2010


Update: Detailed article of this article can be read on

Abu Bakr the Chief of believing pilgrims [9th Hijri year]



1 Comment

Filed under History, Rebuttals

One response to “Answering famous Shia scholar about Abubakr

  1. munawar chohan

    “He(Ali) used to pray the five prayers in the mosque behind Al Siddeeq(Abu Bakr) and he accepted his Imamat and he showed the people that he was in agreement with him and that like liked him.”

    Shia Sources:
    Al Ihtijaj for al Tabrasi p53.
    Kitab Salim bin Qays p203.
    Mira’at al Uqool for Majlisi p388.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s