Another Shia scholar claims Quran was distorted


Shia scholar claims Quran was distorted and corrupted by Uthman and the real Quran is with the hidden 12th Imam of the Shia

Salam `Aleykum,

Shia scholar al-Muhaqqiq Agha Rida bin Muhammad al-Hamdani writes in his book “Misbah-ul-Faqih” speaks about the Sunni chains of Qur’anic recitation and how even the text(Rasm) of the Qur’an we have today is no evidence for the validity of the Sunni recitations because the recitations are corrupt and so is the current Qur’an according to the Imami Shia, he writes:

وأنت خبير بان السند الصحيح بل المتواتر باعتقادهم من أضعف الاسناد عندنا لأنهم يعتمدون في السند على من لا نشك نحن في كذبه واما موافقة أحد المصاحف العثمانية فهي أيضا من الموهنات عندنا سيما مع تمسكهم على اعتبارها باجماع الصحابة عليها الذين جعل الله الرشد في خلافهم حيث إنه غير من القرآن ما شاء ولذا اعرضوا عن مصحف أمير المؤمنين عليه السلام لما عرضه عليهم فأخفاه لولده القائم عليهم السلام وعجل الله فرجه

[You (O reader) are well aware, that the “Sahih” or “Mutawatir” chain of recitation in their view (Ahlul-Sunnah), is from the weakest of chains in our view (Shia view) because their chains rely on men we do not doubt are liars.
As for it (recitation) being supported by any of the `Uthmani Qur’ans (ie their texts), then this also weakens it in our eyes especially since they (Ahlul-Sunnah) believe firmly that the Sahabah all agreed on it, and Allah has placed the guidance in what opposes them (Sahabah), and he (`Uthman) changed in the Qur’an what he wished, this is why they refused the Qur’an of Ameer al-Mu’mineen (as) when he presented it to them, so he hid it for his son al-Qa’im (Mahdi) may Allah hasten his appearance.]

source: Misbah-ul-Faqih 12/115.

Link to scanned document: http://www.dd-sunnah…ad.php?t=171637
Link to Iranian Shia website: http://lib.eshia.ir/10192/2/275

tahreef_shiascholar

By Hani
Posted by 13S2010

5 Comments

Filed under Revealing Shia sect

5 responses to “Another Shia scholar claims Quran was distorted

  1. SHIA SCHOLAR MAY NOT BE WRONG . WHY SHOULD HE? HE FOLLOWS ONLY AHLEBAYT ATHAAR (a s ) , THE MOST IMACULATE, TRUTHFUL & INFALLIBLE , NOT THE MUNAFIQ SHEIKHAINS .
    USMAN REJECTED THE COLLECTIONS OF UMAR , ABU BAKAR, ASKED ALL COPIES TO BE BURNT , RETAINED ON LY HIS OWN COLLECTIONS .
    NOW THE MOTHER OF BELIEVER SAYS HE HAS GONE ASTRAY , HE IS A NATHAL AND A WAJIBUL QATL . HE HAD THE PROVED DISTINCTION OF FLEEING FROM OHUD , RUNNING AWAY, COMING BACK AFTER THREE DAYS . THAT MAKES HIM AS PER QORA’AN A KAFFIR, JAHANNUMI . WILL YOU VOUCH ON THE AUTHENCITY OF THE COPY OF QORA’AN SUCH A MAN COMPILED ? IF YOU DO YOU ARE WELCOME , SHIAS ARE NOT .

    A NATHAL, A KAFFIR’S QORA’AN MAY BE CORRECT OR IT MAY BE CORRUPTED , LIKE HE HIMSELF CORRUPTED . IF YOU HAVE DOUBT , ASK THE SOUL OF HAZRAT ABU ZARR GHAFFARI R.A.A. , THE REAL TRUTHFUL , THE REAL SIDDIQUE SAHABI OF RASOOL E KAREEM (s)
    WHO REPRIMANDED HIM FOR HIS FAVOURITISM , FOR HIS NEPOTISM AND FOR HIS MISAPPROPRIATION OF BAITUL MALL AND THE GREAT OLD REVEREND MAN BANISHED TO DIE IN A LONELY DESERT .SOON
    HE ATTAINED MARTYRDOM AND ALLAH SENT A NOBLE GROUP TO PERFORM HIS BURIAL AND TO TAKE CARE OF A YONG DAUGHTER , THE REVEREND SAHABI HAD LEFT BEHIND IN A DESOLATE DESERT .
    ALA LA’ANATALLAH ALA QAUMIZZALEMEEN, MUNAFEQIN WA KAFFERIN

  2. Samy

    Boss Hamdani is a Culprit not Shia and famous as a CIA funded agent to increase differences in Muslims especially shia’s.
    And when quran says in Surah Baqra” ZALIQAL KITAB U LA RAIBA….”
    So who so ever claims anything conflicting quran, is wrong and liar. There are a few Shiites book that also claim the change in Quran, which is not accepted by majority Shiites scholars same is the case a few of Sunni scholars and books also claim that this is not the same Quran and I know majority of the true Sunni also denies that.
    So peace and stay united,

    • Shiism was invented to create differences between Muslims. And this guy died when CIA didn’t even exist.

      As far your claim that Sunnis also say that “this is not the same Quran” then you are lying. Sunnis have published and spread this Quran and they have mutawatir chains for it.

      • Returning Soul

        Samy didn’t say that all Sunnis believe Quran has been distorted, but only a few of them! So just as the mainstream Shia does not believe in distortion of Quran, so does the mainstream Sunni! However those who do also offer compelling reasons for their opinion that can not be dismissed outright! Their arguments need to be examined with an open mind!

      • Major classical Shia scholars plus thousands of Shia narrations are about the distortions of Quran. Distortion of QUran is a strong view according to Shia texts. But I do agree that majority of Imami Shias TODAY don’t believe in distortion of Quran. Sunnis believe that anyone who claims that Quran has been distorted is outside of the fold of Islam. Sunnis have the Mutawatir chains for the Quran.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s