Shia scholars describe al-Saduq as a LIAR

Written by Hani (aka TripolySunni)

بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم

al-Salamu Aleykum,

The Shia say they believe that the Prophet SAWS does not forget, they attack the rest of the Muslims who do not believe this and claim that we are insulting the Prophet SAWS if we say he makes “Sahu”, little do the Shia know that their scholars hide many things from them and here in the introduction to “Man la Yahduruhu al-Faqih” the Shia scholar al-‘Allamah al-Sheikh Muhammad Jawad al-Faqih writes:

مقدمة كتاب من لايحضره الفقيه – ج 1 – ص 70

9/ جواز السهو على النبي (ص) وسماه اسهاء من الله تعالى تبع في رايه ذلك شيخه محمد بن الحسن بن الوليد وتبعه على رأيه ذلك الشيخ الطبرسي في مجمع البيان كما نقل عنه التنكانبي في قصص العلماء والسيد الجزائري في الانوار النعمانية وفخر الدين الطريحي في مجمع البيان مادة (بدا) والمحقق الفيض الكاشاني في الوافي على مايظهر من كلامه ونقل عن الشيخ البهائي رحمه الله انه قال : ( الحمد لله الذي قطع عمره ولم يوفقه لكتابة مثل ذلك ) ونقل عن الشيخ أحمد الاحسائي انه قال : ( الصدوق في هذه المسألة كذوب ) ولايخلو قولهما من سوء ادب نربأ بامثالهما عن ذلك ونسأل الله العصمة والتوفيق . . . أ.هـ

(9) The permissibility of Sahu (forgetfulness) for the Prophet SAWS: From those who saw this are Muhammad bin al-Hassan bin al-Walid and from those who followed him in his opinion are Sheikh al-Tabrasi in Majma’a al-Bayan as reported from him by Sheikh al-Tinkanbi in Qasas al-‘Ulemaa, also al-Sayyed al-Jazaeri in al-Anwar al-Nu’umaniyyah, also Fakhr al-Deen al-Tarihi in Majma’a al-Bayan and al-Muhaqqiq al-Faydh al-Kashani in al-Wafi from what is apparent.

It is reported by al-Sheikh al-Bahaee (rah) that he said (About al-Saduq): “Praise be to Allah who cut his life and did not allow him to write what he intended.” and Sheikh Ahmad al-Ahissaee said (About al-Saduq): “In this matter al-Saduq is a liar.” both of them have displayed poor Adab by saying this and we did not expect this from people such as them…

source: introduction of Man la Yahduruhu al-Faqih vol.1 pg.70

So based on this, some of the biggest classical Shia scholars on the face of the planet used to believe that the infallible prophet SAWS does forget, from those they named:

1- Ibn Babawei al-Qummi al-Saduq.
2- Muhammad ibn al-Hassan ibn al-Walid.
3- Ameen al-Deen abu ‘Ali al-Fadl bin al-Hussein bin al-Fadl al-Tabrasi.
4- Ni’imatullah al-Jazaeree.
5- Fakhr al-Deen al-Tarihi.
6- al-Faydh al-Kashani.

We also see how some of the shia scholars made Du’ah and thanked Allah for ending the life of al-Saduq as they never agreed with him in matters of ‘Aqeedah.


Filed under Articles, Revealing Shia sect

4 responses to “Shia scholars describe al-Saduq as a LIAR

  1. Do this man Hani knows ascribing falsehood about Imams who are direct successors divinely appointed is a insult to Prophet Mohammad (saaws) .
    All the 12 Imams are immaculate infallible and any one who ascribe Lies
    to them is as if he is blaming on the Rasool (saaws) himself and cannolt
    be any thing but a Kaffir , mutad and Jahannumi . La’anat Allah on any
    who blaspheme Rasool e Akram (saaws) or his Progeny .

  2. The Shia say they believe that the Prophet SAWS does not forget, they attack the rest who do not believe this and claim that they insult the Prophet SAWS
    rather commit blasphemy . Shia’s belief is correct ,if it was not true then the contents of the entire Qora’an could be rendered unreliable . As such every
    devout muslim’s Eemaan is Rasool (s) and his 12 Imams (successors) are all
    free from rijs of any kind , cannot be in dillirium in any circumstaces, can not
    forget , doubtful or out of sense . Any one who ever doubted on His being out
    of senses is a munkir and mutad, Kaffir and Jahannumi ..

  3. My simple question to you , you may not put this question on this page due to some reason

    Hadhrath Fatima Zahra (sa) died 6 months after her father (saaws), Hadhrath Abu Bakr died two and a half years later and Hadhrath Umar in 24 Hijri. Despite their later deaths how is it that they attained burial sites next to the Prophet (saaws) and not Hadhrath Fatima (as)? Did she request that she be buried away from her father? If so, why? Or did the Muslims prevent her burial?
    (see Sahih al Bukhari Arabic – English Vol 5 hadith number 546).


    • Your question has nothing to do with the topic. This time I am approving but if you write irrelevent stuff again (like your brother Zaheer Hussain, whom I believe to be a computer generated spammer, does) then I will not approve it.

      If you want we can discuss this issue on I invite you to come there.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s