Shia killed hussain[ra]: Who took part in it


Here we have discussed part 2 of this series “Shia killed hussain[ra]“: click here

Firstly the Army that attacked Hussein[ra] in karbala:

((وأصبح عمر بن سعد فعبأ أصحابه ، وقد بلغوا إلى ذلك اليوم ثلاثين ألفا ، فجعل الميمنة لعمر وبن الحجاج ، والميسرة لشمر بن ذي الجوشن ، وعلى الخيل عزرة بن قيس ، وعلى الرجالة شبث بن ربعي))
الإرشاد للمفيد ج: / 95

“And they reached thirty thousand on that day, So Amr bin al Hajjaj was given command of the right side of the army, and Shimr bin thu al Jawshan took the left side, The one who was leading the riders was ‘Azrah bin Qays, The one who was leading the foot soldiers was Shibth bin Rab’ee.

source: Al Irshad by shia scholar al Mufid 2/97.

Now who were some of the people who wrote to Hussein RA, so that he might come to kufah and be their Imam:

ثم كتب شبث بن ربعي وحجار بن أبجر ويزيد بن الحارث بن رويم وعزرة بن قيس وعمرو بن الحجاج الزبيدي ومحمد بن عمــــير التميمي، أمّا بعد، فقد اخضرّ الجناب وأينعت الثــمار فإذا شئت فاقــــدم على جند لك مجنّدة والسلام —
المفيد في الإِرشاد ج2 ص37

“Then al Shibth bin Rab’ee, Hijar bin Abjar, Yazid bin al Harith bin Ruwaym, ‘Azrah bin Qays, Amr bin al Hajjaj al Zubaydi, Muhammad bin Umayr al Tamimi they wrote: “The fruits have become ripe for cutting so come to us and you will find a huge army waiting, peace”.

source: Al Irshad by al Mufid 2/37.

and

وكان من المكاتبين حبيب بن مظاهر ، ومسلم بن عوسجة ، وسليمان بن صرد ، ورفاعة بن شداد ، والمسيب بن نجبة ، وشبث بن ربعي ، وحجار ابن أبجر ، ويزيد بن الحرث بن رويم ، وعزرة بن قيس ، وعمرو بن الحجاج ، ومحمد ابن عمير و أمثالهم من الوجوه

المصدر \راجع الإرشاد : 2 / 36 – 37.

From those who wrote to him were Habib bin Muzahir, Muslim bin Awsajah, Suleiman bin Surd, Rifa’ah bin Shaddad, al Museeb bin Najbah, Shibth bin Rab’ee, Hijar bin Abjar, Yazid bin al Harith bin Riwaym, ‘Azrah bin Qays, Amr bin al Hajjaj, Muhammad bin Umayr and their likes”

source: Al Irshad by al Mufid 2/36-37.

Then you have al Shimr, who was he?:

Shimr bin Thu al Jawshan was amongst the supporters of The Caliph Ali PBUH in the battle of Siffin.

Shia sources: Safeenat al bihar by Sheikh al-Tusi 4/3. Bab al Sheen Ba’ad al Meem p492.

زحربن قيس هذا شهد مع علي (ع) الجمل و صفين كما شهد صفين معه شبث بن ربعي و شمر بن ذي الجوشن الضبابي ثم حاربوا الحسين عليه السلام يوم كربلاء (من شيعة أمير المؤمنين علي ) فكانت لهم خاتمة سوء نعوذ بالله من سوء الخاتمة.

المصدر/ في رحاب ائمة اهل‏ البيت(ع) ج 1 ص 9السيد محسن الامين الحسيني العاملي

This Zhr bin Qays had witnessed the battle of JAMAL and SIFFIN alongside Ameer al Mumineen Ali PBUH as well as al-Shibth bin Rab’ee and Shimr bin thu al Jawshan al Dababi, then they fought against al Hussein PBUH on the day of Karbala so they had a horrible ending and we seek refuge in Allah from such an ending”.

source: Fi Rihab AhlulBayt 1/9 by Al Sayyed Muhsin al Ameen al Husseini al Amili.

So who were the Men that lead the army against Hussein RA?:

1- Amro bin Sa’ad.
2- Shimr bin thu al Jawshan who led the left side. (was a Shia who fought under Caliph Ali RA in Siffin).
3- Amr bin al Hajjaj who leads the right side. ( wrote to Hussein RA telling him to come to kufah )
4- ‘Azarah bin Qays leader of the riders. ( wrote to Hussein RA telling him to come to kufah )
5- Shibth bin Rab’ee leader of the foot soldiers. ( wrote to Hussein RA telling him to come to kufah )

The one to expose them was their own imam al Hussein RA who called the leaders of this army (All Shia) by their names on the battle field and told them:

((يا شبث بن ربعي، يا حجار بن أبجر، يا قيس بن الاشعث، يا يزيد بن الحارث، ألم تكتبوا إلي أن قد أينعت الثمار واخضر الجناب، وإنما تقدم على جند لك مجندة ؟ وناداهم الحر بن يزيد أحد أصحاب الحسين وهو واقف في كربلاء فقال لهم :أدعوتم هذا العبد الصالح حتى إذا جاءكم أسلمتموه ثم عدوتم عليه لتقتلوه فصار كالأسير في أيديكم؟لا سقاكم الله يوم الظمأ..))..الإرشاد للمفيد.
! الارشاد ج2 ص 98

O Shibth bin Rab’ee, O Hijar bin Abjar, O Qays bin al Asha’ath, O Yazid bin al Harith didn’t you write to me that the fruits had become ripe for cutting and that I come to you and find a huge army to support me?”
source: Al Irshad by al Mufid 2/98.

Comment: As you can see those who supported Ali[ra] in the battle of SIFFIN against Muawiyah[ra] {father of yazid}, killed Hussain[ra]. & these peoples are those who was called as SHIAN-E-ALI.

6 Comments

Filed under Articles, Revealing Shia sect

6 responses to “Shia killed hussain[ra]: Who took part in it

  1. ajk

    Can we get the sanned images plz?

  2. Syed Ali Abbas

    I can see that you said the above fought with Imam Ali (as) against Mauvia and you showed that Imam Ali as was on write and those you mentioned betrayed him in Karbala. So in Sifin Imam Ali (as) was right so mauvia who was a father of Yazid the leader in Karbala (you can say shiya) fought against. And I can see you mentioned RA ahead of mauvia. What logics you do have, that at one end you are supporting Imam Ali as right and also the enemy of Imam Ali in sifin? secondly when it comes to Karbala you states that shia killed and say yazid is shiya, so mauvia is also shiya? because yazid took revenge of his father (LA). Now you will say sifin was also with shiya or what? you must know the shahadat of Amar bin Yasir? for whom Prophet SAWW said to him, you’ll be murdered by rebels. so Mauvia being a rebel is you Ameer? if so, then you are from a party of rebel. Now, If shiya killed, then can you curse the killers and their ancestors? I can show you a brief linkage of Shia & others family background – Shiya are followers of Imam Ali as with twelve Imam (whom you quoted every where as truth) syeds the family members of Prophet are all shiya except those who went remote areas. (so prophet family betrayed?) shiya shiya beliefs of Prophet SAWW are much higher than others with references. Now have a look on Yours, Abu Sufiyan your beloved (Wife Hinda who ate liver of Uncle of Prophet SAWW), Marwan your beloved, whom Prophet SAWW thrown off from the city to come but mauvia brought him back (disobedience), Abu Bakr who declared Liar to Fatima (SA) daughter of Prophet, who torn the writing of Prophet SAWW. Mauvia (who fought 70+ fights with Imam Ali (as) but he is not shiya? yazid his son who took revenge (is shiya) and Dr. Zakir Naik (Your Famous religious scholar) says may Allah pleases with him (LA) so he being a sunni/wahabi or whatever praising shiyas too? Ameer Mukhtar (AS) who killed yazid and his companions can you praise him? if he killed shiya then you should.

    All way in your posts, it mentioned O’ you who did this who did this. where is shiya mentioned? You have been stamped on your heart of non-believers, you guys will never accept the truth but take it in your favour. Your life is useless and your death will define you your way to hell.

  3. Syed Ali Abbas

    and you don’t belief the twelve Imam (As) as well. and had made 4 imams, whose sayings are contradictory to each other and you are following? In karbala there were 72 people with Ahle-bayt (as) and 30000 munafiqs and today there is the same ratio where we shiya are still as 72 and you guys are like those 30k.

    • Ibn Abdullah

      1.72 were Ahle bait with some loyal companions of hussain
      2.30k were – Shia of Ali+Munafiqs+worst leaders
      3. Addressing of Musa al-Kazim (ra):

      If I had to truly distinguish my Shî‘ah I would find them nothing other than pretenders. If I had to put them to the test I would only find them to be apostates. If I were to scrutinise them I would be left with only one in a thousand. Were I to sift them thoroughly I would be left with only the handful that is truly mine. They have been sitting on cushions all along, saying: ” We are the Shî‘ah of ‘Alî.”

      Source: al-Kulayni, Rawdat al-Kafi vol. 8 p. 288

  4. Syed Omer Ali Shah

    Early Sunni and the early Shia books Ali said:”With regard to me, two categories of people will be ruined, namely he who loves me too much and the love takes him away from rightfulness, and he who hates me too much and the hatred takes him away from rightfulness. The best man with regard to me is he who is on the middle course. So be with him and be with the great majority of Muslims because Allah’s hand of protection is on keeping unity. You should beware of division because the one isolated from the group is a prey to Satan just as the one isolated from the flock of sheep is a prey to the wolf. Beware! Whoever calls to this course [of sectarianism], kill him, even though he may be under this headband of mine.”(Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 126)

  5. shaz rahman

    in reality, if you blame the shia for not helping imam hussain from kufa,then you yazeed was the sunni. Do you not forget that ibn ziyad threatened the supporters of imam hussain? do you sunnies actually believe that the battle of siffin was between two sahabas? The simple word is ‘LOGIC’.you people do not realize that if a man killed another man, it is called murdering mankind. There was no accident in killing someone. Mu’awiya was a rebelious munafiq. His father caused the tooth of the prophet to be broken, his mother killed hazrat hamza and ate his liver. His son killed imam hussain and you think Mu’awiya has any status in islam? You sunni people used to accept these facts; but under the influence of saudi arabia and wahabies you think that you are on the right path. I used to be a sunni but then i converted to becoming a shia of Ali because of your nonsense..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s