shia alim Kulayni on Tahreef in Quran & authenticity of Al-kafi


Mr. Kulayni who wrote the Book al Kafi,

in its Intro he wrote:

“Verily, you solemnly wished that you possess a book which is sufficient, brings together the entire Islamic sciences of the knowledge of religion within it, wholly satisfies the needs of the student, acts as a reference for the seekers of guidance, and would be used by those who want to attain the knowledge of religion and practice upon it by deriving correct [şaĥīĥ] narrations of the truthful ones (as) and the upright and acted upon traditions from it—through which the compulsory duties of Allāh, the Powerful and Exalted, and the tradition of His Prophet (saws) can be fulfilled.
And you said: ‘If that happens, I can hope that (the book) would be a means through which Allāh will rectify our brothers and people of our religious community through his support and grace, and take them closer to their salvation.’”

Source:al-Kāfī, of Abū Ja`far al-Kulaynī (d. 329), volume 1, page 8 [Tehran]

Let’s see what his friends think of him.

المفسر الكبير محمد بن مرتضى الكاشاني الملقب بـ (الفيض الكاشاني) :
قال : ” وأما اعتقاد مشايخنا في ذلك فالظاهر من ثقة الاسلام محمد بن يعقوب الكليني طاب ثراه أنه كان يعتقد التحريف والنقصان في القرآن لأنه كان روى روايات في هذا المعنى في كتابه الكافي ولم يتعرض للقدح فيها مع انه ذكر في أول الكتاب أنه كان يثق بما رواه فيه
تفسير الصافي 1/52 منشورات الاعلمي – بيروت .

The Great Shiite Classical mufassir and Scholar Ibn al murtada al Kashani also known as al Faydh al Kashani said:
As for the belief of our scholars in that Matter (Distortion of the Quran) it’s apparent from thiqat al Islam The Scholar Muhammad Bin ya’aqoob al kulayni May allah reward him That he used to believe in the Distortion of the Quran in terms of deletion, this is because He narrated Narrations which prove this and didn’t even criticize them although he narrated at the beginning of his book that he was confident in all that he narrated in it.

Source: Tafseer al Safi 1/52, Beirut.

أبو الحسن العاملي :

قال : اعلم أن الذي يظهر من ثقة الاسلام محمد بن يعقوب الكليني طاب ثراه أنه كان يعتقد التحريف والنقصان في القرآن لأنه روى روايات كثيرة في هذا المعنى في كتاب الكـــافي الذي صرح في أوله بأنه كان يثق فيما رواه فيه ولم يتعرض لقدح فيها ولا ذكر معارض لها

المقدمة الثانية الفصل الرابع تفسير مرآة الانوار ومشكاة الاسرار وطبعت كمقدمه لتفسير البرهان للبحراني .

The Big Scholar Abu al hassan al Amili said:

I Know that what’s apparent regarding Thikat al Islam Muhammad Bin Ya’aqoob al Kulayni May allah reward him is That he believed in the distortion of the Quran and its deletion because he narrated so many Narrations to that effect in his book al Kafi in which he stated at the beginning ( of the book) that he trusts all that he narrates in it and he didn’t criticize those narrations nor did he oppose them.
Source: Second introduction from the 4th Fasl, Tafseer Mira’at al Anwar wa Mishkat al Asrar, and it was printed as an introduction for “Tafseer al Burhan” for the scholar al Bahrani.

النوري الطبرسي :

قال النوري في المقدمة الثالثة في ذكر أقوال علماء الشيعة في تغيير القرآن ص 23 : ” اعلم أن لهم في ذلك أقوالاً مشهورها اثنان . الأول : وقوع التغيير والنقصان فيه ، وهو مذهب الشيخ الجليل علي بن إبراهيم القمي شيخ الكليني في تفسيره صرح في أوله وملأ كتابه من أخباره مع التزامه في أوله بأن لا يذكر فيه إلا عن مشايخه وثقاته ومذهب تلميذه ثقة الإسلام الكليني رحمه الله على نسبه إليه جماعة لنقله الأخبار الكثيرة الصريحة في هذا المعنى في كتاب الحجة خصوصاً في باب النكت والنتف من التنزيل وفي الروضة من غير تعرض لردها أو تأويلها
فصل الخطاب في اثبات تحريف كتاب رب الارباب ص 23

Giant scholar Al Noori al Tabrasi said:

In the third introduction in which he states the Sayings of Shia scholars about the Distortion of the Quran Page 23: I Know that they have two popular sayings. The first: That Corruption did in fact take place in form of change and of deletion, and that is the Madhab of the Respected Sheikh Ali bin Ibrahim al Qummi, Kulayni’s Scholar who in his Tafseer says this in the introduction and fills his book with such sayings and he only mentioned these sayings from his Own Scholars (teachers) and his trustworthy sources, also it is the Madhab of his Student thiqat al islam al Kulayni May allah have mercy on his soul in which he transmitted many clear Sarih Sayings which prove this (Tahreef) and especially in his “Kitab’ul Hujjah” in the chapter ‘Al Nakt wal Natf min al Tanzeel’ and in His “al Rawdah” without criticizing any of them or refuting them.

Source: Fasl al Khitab fi Ithbat Tahreef Kitab rabb al arbab Page 23, tehran.

آية الله السيد على الفاني الاصفهاني :

وقد ذكر الكليني من العلماء الذين قالوا بأن القرآن محرف
آراء حول القرآن – دار الهادي – بيروت ص 188

grand Ayatullah Sayyed Ali al Fani al Isfahani:

“And Kulayni is mentioned amongst those scholars who Say that the Quran is Corrupt

Source: Ara’a Hawl al Quran – Darul Hadee – Beirut Page 188.

Comment: This is mazhab of shia rafida’s. The first scholar of shia believe in distortion of quran & this shia rafida worship this dog.

1 Comment

Filed under Revealing Shia sect, Tahreef in Quran

One response to “shia alim Kulayni on Tahreef in Quran & authenticity of Al-kafi

  1. Pingback: Tahreef in Quran – 3 « EXPOSING & ANSWERING SHIITES

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s